Regardless of your personal views, music has been used as political commentary for decades. In my final blog post, I will showcase two examples of songs with deeper political meanings and analyze some elements of music within them.
First up is Jack Johnson’s My Mind is For Sale! This is one of my personal favorites from his newest album. It is consistent with the gentle nature of his typical work. However, this piece has an incredibly deep message that is surprising to hear from Johnson.
Lyrics
“I don’t care for your paranoid
“Us against them” walls
I don’t care for your careless
“Me first, gimme gimme” appetite at all”
Jack Johnson wrote these lyrics to communicate his frustrations with the current administration. He refers to “the wall,” which was a prevalent and controversial issue throughout the Trump Campaign. These lyrics are repeated throughout the song and serve as the chorus. From Johnson’s perspective, the Trump Administration is careless, paranoid, and greedy.
In 2017, Rolling Stones published an article that stated: “’My Mind is For Sale’ is packed with sharp lyrics skewering President Trump, but Johnson delivers his barbs with a gentle and dexterous touch over an effervescent instrumental groove” (Blistein, 2017).
Meter
After listening to this piece several times, I was able to determine that this song’s meter is in four. I thought it was particularly interesting because the pace of this song is mellow and relaxing. Throughout this course we have seen a variety of different types of music (pop, classical, etc.) that fall into meter of four. I thought this relatively ‘slow’ song was a unique addition to our classes’ collection.
Dynamics
Jack Johnson’s pieces are typically mellow, wholesome, and simple. This song is a perfect example of another relatively ‘soft’ and gentle composition from Jack Johnson. Despite the deep political message, this song’s soft nature is relaxing and calming.
__________________________________________________________
The second piece I decided to analyze was Strange Fruit by Billie Holiday. This song was recorded and released in 1939 (wikipedia.com). Billie Holiday’s voice is raspy, soulful, and communicates a message filled with deep sorrow. It is an incredibly moving song.
Lyrics
“Southern trees bear strange fruit,
Blood on the leaves and blood at the root,
Black bodies swinging in the southern breeze,
Strange fruit hanging from the poplar trees.”
This song was written in response to the lynching that was taking place in the United States in the 1930s. Although the majority of lynching occurred during the late 1800s, black people were still being targeted when this song was released. The lyrics are harrowing and convey a horrifying political message (wikipedia.com).
Meter
I had a difficult time determining what the meter of this composition is. After checking the sheet music, I was able to confirm that the meter was in four. The piece is even slower than the Jack Johnson piece that I analyzed. This again proved to me that songs of all tempos can have a meter in four.
Dynamics
I would categorize this composition as soft. This version is simply Billie Holiday singing accompanied by a gentle piano. The lyrics and message are bold, loud, and disturbing, but the piece overall is relatively soft.
Work Cited
“All the Light Above It Too.” Wikipedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 12 Dec. 2018, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_the_Light_Above_It_Too.
Blistein, Jon, and Jon Blistein. “Jack Johnson Breaks Walls in Sly Anti-Trump ‘My Mind Is for Sale’ Video.” Rolling Stone, 25 June 2018, http://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-news/jack-johnson-breaks-walls-in-sly-anti-trump-my-mind-is-for-sale-video-201376/.
“Strange Fruit.” Wikipedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 18 Apr. 2019, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strange_Fruit.

